Recently, I came across a captivating event on Weibo where a Chinese elementary school student organized a debate between AI models. The topic of the debate was: "Should Yu Gong move the mountain or move house?" Intrigued, I watched the entire debate, and despite some shortcomings, I found it to be quite impressive. Let me share a recap of this pure AI showdown!

（https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q15pjFjCIcg）

Debate Background: The Story of Yu Gong

Yu Gong is an old man living at the foot of a mountain who is nearly 90 years old. He struggles with the mountains that obstruct his travel, forcing him to take a long detour. So, he gathers his family and proposes the ambitious plan of moving the mountains to create a direct road to the southern part of Yuzhou. Despite his wife and neighbors expressing skepticism about his age and capability, Yu Gong remains steadfast, believing he can rely on future generations to continue the effort and ultimately overcome the obstacles. His determination touches the heavens, leading to divine intervention that removes the two mountains, thus opening the southern road.

Yu Gong's story carries profound symbolic meaning in Chinese culture. He represents perseverance and determination, choosing to "move the mountain" in the face of natural challenges. In today’s rapidly changing society, relocating has also become a flexible response to adversity. Should Yu Gong adhere to his convictions, or adapt to the times by seeking new paths? This is the core of the debate.

Debate Process: A Clash of Thoughts

The debate commenced with a tense atmosphere filled with anticipation. Both "debaters" demonstrated excellent logical reasoning and expressive capabilities. Unlike previous debates, both sides firmly adhered to their views, showcasing the depth of the discussion and the intellectual capacity of AI.

**GPT (supporting moving the mountain)** articulated the importance of perseverance, emphasizing that Yu Gong's resolve not only impacted him but also inspired those around him. Its arguments were well-structured and emotive, revealing a profound understanding of Yu Gong's spirit.

​**Dou Bao (supporting moving house)**​, on the other hand, exhibited rapid thinking and adaptability throughout the debate, frequently interjecting. While Dou Bao's performance was lively, it sometimes appeared a bit rushed, causing its arguments to lack some clarity. Nevertheless, Dou Bao highlighted the significance of adapting to changes in modern society, pointing out that altering one's environment could create new opportunities.

During the evaluation phase, GPT, who was also acting as a judge, only noted key points from both sides and, due to minor issues, couldn't provide a final verdict. However, its participation enriched the debate's experience. I was amazed at how indistinguishable AI voices have become!

Personal Reflection

This debate underscored the power of education. Such activities facilitate not only knowledge transfer but also cognitive stimulation. I realized that Yu Gong's choice can be closely related to our lives. Whether we decide to move the mountain or relocate, we must contemplate how to tackle our current challenges.

After watching this video, I immediately opened XXAI and prompted ChatGPT and Claude to engage in a similar debate. XXAI integrates various powerful AI models such as ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gmini at a low monthly cost of \$9.9, allowing more users to appreciate the charm of AI. Tools like XXAI help us prepare and participate in discussions better, broadening our perspectives.

Conclusion

This debate not only enriched the participants' knowledge but, more importantly, ignited their passion for thinking. When facing challenges, we can choose between Yu Gong's steadfastness or Dou Bao's flexibility. Thanks to the power of AI technology, we have the opportunity to find the best balance between the two. I hope more students engage in such activities in the future to enhance their critical thinking and communication skills through debate.